The Pros and Cons of Refinancing Application Fees

What lenders charge to set up a new home loan, when the cost is worth paying, and how Bentleigh homeowners can weigh it up.

Hero Image for The Pros and Cons of Refinancing Application Fees

A refinance application fee is only one line in the cost of switching, and it should be weighed against what the new loan saves you.

For homeowners in Bentleigh, the real question is whether the new loan will repay its costs and still suit your plans. This article looks at both sides, so you can judge the fee on its merits.

What Is a Refinance Application Fee?

An application fee is a charge some lenders apply to set up and assess a new loan. Lenders set these amounts themselves, so they vary from one lender to the next.

The fee sits alongside other possible costs of a refinance. ASIC's Moneysmart lists a break fee on a fixed rate loan, a discharge or termination fee on closing your current loan, an application fee on the new loan, and a switching fee if you refinance internally with your current lender. Each is a separate line, so ask for all of them in writing before you commit.

The Pros: When Paying the Fee Makes Sense

The fee makes sense when the new loan saves you more than the switch costs. That can happen through a lower interest rate, features that suit you, or a loan structure that improves your cashflow.

An application fee is usually a one-off cost. A lower rate may reduce your repayments for as long as the rate difference lasts, but variable rates can change, so a saving is not certain to continue. Features such as an offset account or redraw facility can also suit your habits more closely than your current loan does. Some borrowers also use a refinance to consolidate other debts into their mortgage. Our debt consolidation page explains how that works.

One trade-off applies here. If a lower repayment comes only from a longer loan term, you will usually pay more interest over the life of the loan, so that kind of saving does not reduce your total cost. ASIC expects borrowers to be told this directly.

The Cons: Where Application Fees Can Work Against You

The main downside is that costs paid upfront can outweigh the savings, particularly if you sell or refinance again within a short time. A small rate difference may not repay the fee for many months.

Broker fees also count towards the total cost of switching under ASIC's guidance, and a broker must recommend a refinance only when it meets the statutory standard of acting in your interests. Sometimes that means advising you to stay where you are. If your current loan is fixed, a break fee may be far larger than the application fee, so check that first. Our page on fixed rate expiry covers the timing of that decision.

Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance Broker at Finance Broker Melbourne today.

How to Work Out the Break-Even Point on Switching Costs

The break-even point is the total cost of switching divided by your monthly saving. It tells you how many months you need to stay in the new loan before you come out ahead.

Consider a Bentleigh homeowner with a $600,000 balance and 25 years remaining. At an illustrative rate of 6.75% p.a., the repayment is about $4,146 a month. Suppose a refinance lowers that repayment by $150 a month, and the application, discharge and other switching costs total an assumed $1,200. Dividing $1,200 by $150 gives a break-even point of eight months.

The homeowner plans to stay in the home for years, so the switch pays for itself and keeps saving after month eight, provided the rate difference holds. If they planned to sell within six months, the same switch would leave them behind. The numbers are illustrative only, and you can test your own through our repayments page or a lender calculator.

Which Other Costs Should You Check Before Switching?

Beyond the application fee, check for a break fee, a discharge fee, and lenders mortgage insurance if your equity is under 20%. Moneysmart notes that borrowers with less than 20% equity might have to pay it, which can add to the cost of switching.

Exit fees are treated differently. For credit contracts entered into on or after 1 July 2011 and secured over residential property, regulations prohibit a fee on termination. That prohibition does not cover break fees or discharge fees, so those can still apply. Victoria abolished mortgage duty from 1 July 2004, but Moneysmart still suggests asking your lender about any stamp duty, and our stamp duty page has more detail.

If you are on an Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme loan, refinancing to a lender that is not a Participating Lender ends the scheme's benefit. A lender may then impose lenders mortgage insurance or other costs, so raise this early.

Are Refinancing Costs Tax Deductible on an Investment Property?

Some borrowing expenses on a rental property loan may be deductible, but the home loan on your own residence is treated differently. Speak to your accountant about your situation, as no outcome is certain.

The ATO lists loan establishment fees, mortgage broker fees and valuation fees required for loan approval among borrowing expenses. Where total borrowing expenses exceed $100, they are generally deducted over five years or the loan term, whichever is shorter. Any part of the loan used for private purposes cannot be deducted. If you are weighing up an investment loan, have your accountant review how a refinance affects the interest you claim.

Checking Whether a Switch Suits You First

A review of your current loan shows whether a switch is likely to pay off before you spend anything on fees. A loan health check compares your rate, features and costs with what is available to you, depending on your deposit size and lender.

Our refinancing team works with Bentleigh homeowners in postcode 3204 and can price the whole switch, not only the application fee. Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you, and we will tell you plainly whether refinancing is worth it or whether staying put is the smarter move.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a refinance application fee?

It is a charge some lenders apply to set up and assess a new home loan. Amounts are set by each lender, so compare them in writing before you proceed.

How do I know if a refinance is worth the fees?

Divide your total switching costs by your expected monthly saving to find the break-even point in months. If you plan to hold the new loan well beyond that point and the saving lasts, the switch is more likely to pay off.

Can a lender charge an exit fee when I refinance?

For credit contracts entered into on or after 1 July 2011 and secured over residential property, fees on termination are prohibited. Break fees on fixed rate loans and discharge fees are not covered by that prohibition.

Are refinance costs tax deductible?

Some borrowing expenses on an investment property loan may be deductible over time, but private-use loans are treated differently. Speak to your accountant about your circumstances.


Ready to get started?

Book a chat with a Finance Broker at Finance Broker Melbourne today.